The Alabama Crimson Tide, once an unstoppable force in college football, have seen some turbulence in recent seasons. For years, Alabama dominated the SEC and NCAA rankings under legendary coach Nick Saban, routinely earning playoff berths and competing for national championships. But as the landscape of college football continues to evolve, with new faces in key programs and fierce competition, the question now is: Does Alabama still have what it takes to make a serious playoff push in 2025?
Alabama’s 2024 season started with optimism but quickly became a reality check. While the program remains one of the most respected in college football, the Tide have struggled to find consistency in some key areas, after a somewhat underwhelming 2023 season, where they lost in the SEC Championship to Georgia, Alabama’s hopes of making a playoff appearance in 2024 hinge on overcoming some serious challenges.
The quarterback position, historically a cornerstone for the Tide’s success, has been a point of uncertainty in recent years. Despite bringing in talented quarterbacks like Jalen Milroe and Ty Simpson, the offense hasn’t fully clicked the way many fans and analysts expect. Milroe has shown flashes of brilliance, but inconsistent play and mistakes at inopportune times have held the offense back from reaching its full potential.
Alabama still has an incredible recruiting class, with some of the best athletes in the nation, but there is a growing sense that their once-dominant style of play—defined by powerful defense and a bruising ground game—has been overshadowed by a shift toward high-scoring, pass-heavy offenses across the country.
The Alabama offense has certainly had its moments, but there’s no question that it has been far from flawless in recent seasons. With the emergence of more high-powered, modern offenses in college football, Alabama’s offense has often appeared sluggish and predictable. This has especially been evident in key matchups where they’ve faced up-tempo, dynamic offenses, struggling to match the speed and precision of teams like Georgia, Tennessee, and LSU.
Milroe, while physically gifted and capable of making spectacular plays with his legs, has yet to show he can consistently be the pocket passer Alabama needs. The offensive line, once a hallmark of Alabama football, has also seen some struggles in recent years. In the 2024 season, Alabama has faced challenges in establishing a balanced attack, with some games seeing underwhelming production in the passing game and a lack of dominance in the running game.
For Alabama to have a chance at making the playoffs, the offense needs to show up in big games and be more consistent. If Milroe can improve his decision-making and develop a quicker, more accurate passing game, it could help Alabama regain its place among the nation’s elite.
Alabama’s defense remains one of the team’s strongest assets. With a slew of talented defensive players, including standout linebacker Dallas Turner, and a top-tier secondary, the Crimson Tide continue to be a force to be reckoned with. Alabama’s defense can shut down the run game, pressure opposing quarterbacks, and force turnovers. They’ve been a top unit in college football for years, and that hasn’t changed.
However, while Alabama’s defense has remained elite, there have been instances where it has been caught off guard by the speed and versatility of some of the newer offensive schemes across the SEC and beyond. In 2024, they’ve given up big plays at times, especially in fast-paced, high-scoring games, which is something they’ll need to address if they are to make a deep playoff run.
Defensive coordinator Kevin Steele will need to continue adjusting to the changing college football landscape, ensuring that the defense is not only stout against the run but also capable of containing more dynamic passing attacks.
One of the biggest obstacles for Alabama’s playoff hopes is the SEC itself. The SEC West is loaded with talent, and perennial powerhouse teams like Georgia, LSU, and Tennessee are all gunning for a spot in the College Football Playoff. Georgia, in particular, remains a dominant force, having won consecutive national titles and showing no signs of slowing down. The Tide will need to beat out these teams in both the regular season and potentially in the SEC Championship Game if they want to secure one of the coveted playoff spots.
Alabama has struggled to maintain the same level of dominance in recent seasons, and the increased competition from other SEC teams, particularly Georgia, has made it more difficult for Alabama to stay on top. With a likely rematch against Georgia in the SEC Championship on the horizon, the Tide’s path to the playoffs is anything but easy.
Despite the challenges, Alabama is still very much in the hunt for a playoff spot. The team has the talent, the coaching, and the pedigree to make a run, but it will need to show more consistency across the board. If the offense can start clicking and reduce mistakes, particularly at the quarterback position, Alabama can still compete with the best of them.
However, making the playoffs in 2024 will require Alabama to go undefeated in the regular season and then win the SEC Championship. Even a one-loss season could leave them on the outside looking in, especially with the stiff competition from other conferences and teams. Their chances are further complicated by the fact that a second loss would almost certainly eliminate them from contention.
In the end, while Alabama still has a solid chance to make the playoffs, the margin for error has never been thinner. With rising competition, the Tide will need to prove that they can adapt to the modern era of college football and recapture the dominance that once made them a playoff fixture. Time will tell if Nick Saban can lead them back to the postseason, but for now, Alabama’s playoff hopes remain very much alive—if they can make the necessary adjustments.
Leave a Reply